Lenny Bruce’s Obscenity Trial Challenged First Amendment Rights and Paved the Way for Other Socially Conscious Comedians

One of the most influential stand-ups in history, Lenny Bruce burst onto the stage in the 1950s, forever changing comedy with his free-form, no-holds-barred performances. His caustic social commentary made him a legend. But it also made him a target for his critics and law enforcement, leading to an infamous 1964 arrest that put both Bruce and free speech on trial.

Bruce found his comedic voice early in his career

The son of a shoe clerk and a dancer, Long Island-born Leonard Schneider turned to entertainment following a teenage stint in the U.S. Navy during World War II and made his first appearance as an emcee at a Brooklyn nightclub shortly after his return from service.

Bruce’s early work was traditional, focusing on inoffensive material like celebrity parodies and impressions, which earned him bookings on radio variety programs. But Bruce soon grew dissatisfied. A fan of Beat generation artists and writers and a music devotee, he was deeply influenced by the free-flowing, improvisational nature of jazz, which he thought he could adapt for his stage performances, along with his own dark, satirical view of once-taboo topics like politics, religion, race, sex, and drugs (Bruce’s own drug addiction began during this period).

After marrying and moving to California, Bruce began workshopping his new act, gaining fans and detractors. Many were shocked not only by his foul language but by his subject matter.

As his career progressed, no topic or person would be spared, as he railed against the perceived hypocrisy of establishment figures and launched scathing criticisms of religious, social and political leaders. Not even first ladies like Eleanor Roosevelt or Jacqueline Kennedy would be spared, leading the mainstream media to brand him a “sick comic.”

By the mid-1950s, Bruce was performing across the country and released a series of comedy albums. But his increasing notoriety and refusal to conform resulted in his being blacklisted from many popular television shows, due to fears that his provocative act would offend complacent Eisenhower-era audiences. He made just a handful of appearances on national network television during his career, and those shows that he did book often tried to censor his material. Despite this, he continued to make a name for himself, and in February 1961 he played a landmark gig at New York’s Carnegie Hall, which many historians consider to be the apex of his career.

His legal troubles began just months after his great success

Bruce’s troubled marriage to a stripper and showgirl led to his involvement in a financial fraud for which he was arrested by not convicted. But his controversial act and lifestyle caught the eyes of law enforcement across the country. He was arrested on drug abuse charges in Philadelphia and obscenity charges in San Francisco in late 1961 but was acquitted. A 1962 drug charge in Los Angeles was dropped, but in 1963, he was convicted of obscenity in Chicago, after being arrested on stage. In increasing ill health due to his looming legal troubles and worsening drug addiction, Bruce decided to return to New York.

But powerful forces were already coalescing against him. Manhattan District Attorney Frank Hogan, working in conjunction with local church officials, including Archbishop Francis Cardinal Spellman, began their own investigation of Bruce. When he was booked at the popular Greenwich Village nightclub Café au Go Go in spring 1964, undercover detectives surreptitiously recorded two of his shows, which they presented to a grand jury to obtain an indictment. In early April, Bruce was arrested, charged with violating New York Penal Code 1140, barring obscene material that could aid in the “corruption of morals of youth and others,” and faced a maximum punishment of three years in prison. The club’s owner was also arrested, for allowing Bruce to perform the material.

Dozens of notable artists signed a petition denouncing Bruce’s arrest, including actors Paul Newman, Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton, writers Susan Sontag, Norman Mailer and James Baldwin, singer Bob Dylan and fellow comedians, including Woody Allen. It read, in part, “Whether we regard Bruce as a moral spokesman or simply as an entertainer, we believe he should be allowed to perform free from censorship or harassment."

Bruce hired a team of prominent First Amendment attorneys, including Ephraim London, who would later argue a number of free speech cases before the U.S. Supreme Court. When the trial began that July, the jam-packed courtroom listened as the prosecution laid out its case, including audio recordings of Bruce’s performances and re-enactments of his routines by undercover cops, including what prosecutors alleged was an act of simulated on-stage masturbation. Bruce responded by critiquing their poor performance of his work.

Bruce’s hospitalization delayed the proceedings, and he used this time to brush up on legal statutes, becoming increasingly involved in his own defense (and later unsuccessfully demanding he be allowed to testify). When the trial resumed, his team called a number of witnesses, including literary critics and psychologists, aimed at proving that while Bruce’s material may have been offensive, it was not sexually provocative enough to warrant a conviction under the wording of the New York State statutes. One of the most prominent witnesses was Dorothy Kilgallen, a conservative New York newspaper columnist whose social position and political beliefs, Bruce’s team hoped, would counterbalance his anti-establishment notoriety.

Bruce lost his case but left both a political and comedic legacy

It took three months for the three-judge panel to issue its verdict. In November 1964, Bruce, who had already fired his attorneys, was convicted, as was club owner Howard Solomon (Solomon’s sentence was later overturned). At a hearing a month later, Bruce launched into an hour-long defense but was sentenced to four months in a workhouse.

He remained out on bail, pending an appeal, but was virtually unemployable. What few dates he did book could barely cover his drug habit or legal bills, which continued to pile up as an embittered Bruce filed a series of unsuccessful civil suits against his opponents. On August 3, 1966, Bruce was found dead of a morphine overdose at his Los Angeles home, aged just 40 years old.

Bruce became a free-speech martyr, as others continued to push past the boundaries he had faced, including Richard Pryor, who was deeply impacted by Bruce’s work and credited him with inspiring his own transition to a more confrontational form of comedy in the late 1960s and George Carlin, who rose to fame with his monologue on “seven dirty words” just a few years after Bruce’s death. In 1973, the U.S. Supreme Court reversed years of earlier precedent in the landmark case Miller v. California, which broadened First Amendment protection for material like Bruce’s, based on an argument of the material’s underlying literary, artistic and social value.

In 2003, Bruce’s fellow comics came to his defense again, as Robin Williams, Penn & Teller and others joined free speech advocates and lawyers in a petition to New York Governor George Pataki. That December, 37 years after his death, Bruce received a posthumous pardon for his 1964 conviction.

ncG1vNJzZmivp6x7o7XOoKmaqJiue6S7zGilnq%2BjZLmmus2yZJuqpZiybrvBrJqeppmpxm7A0aKYpQ%3D%3D